Recorded October 12, 2026. Figures and market conditions reflect information available on that date and may have changed since. Independent research by Todd Hanley; not the views of United Direct Lending.
Full script
Read the full script
Most people hear the word “denied” and immediately assume the problem is their credit score.
But a mortgage file is not one number. It is a system, and the best way to understand a problem is to diagnose four separate parts: credit, income, property, and capital.
In 2024 HMDA data analyzed by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, those four categories accounted for about 80.7% of primary mortgage-denial reasons.
First is income, which represented 37%. This includes debt-to-income ratio and employment history. The important point is that the limit is not universal. Fannie Mae manual underwriting generally starts at 36% and may stretch to 45% when the required credit and reserve conditions are met. Desktop Underwriter can evaluate files up to 50%. Some specialized programs can go higher.
Second is credit at 28.5%. Here again, one number does not tell the whole story. Fannie Mae manual underwriting lists minimum scores, but Desktop Underwriter does not use one universal minimum score. FHA also changes significantly by score. Below 500 is ineligible, 500 through 579 is generally capped at 90% loan-to-value, and 580 or higher can access maximum FHA financing, subject to the full file.
Third is the property at 9.9%. A borrower can qualify while the building, appraisal, condition, insurance, or condo project does not. In 2026, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac changed multiple condo-review paths. Limited or streamlined review was retired for newer applications, while some small projects gained waiver or exemption options. Reserve-study and budget requirements also became more important.
Fourth is capital at 5.3%. This means the down payment, closing funds, and required reserves. Having money is not always enough. The lender may need to verify where it came from, whether a large deposit is sourced, whether gift funds are allowed, and whether business assets or converted cryptocurrency meet the program’s documentation rules.
So if a lender says no, do not treat that as a diagnosis. Ask which of the four parts failed, which rule controlled the decision, and whether a different program or a better-prepared file changes the answer.
Credit. Income. Property. Capital. Find the real obstacle before you change the entire plan.
Want to talk through your own numbers?
Independent research and commentary. The research, data analysis, and opinions in this video and on this page are Todd Hanley's own and do not represent the views of United Direct Lending. They are not lending advice and are not tied to any loan program, product, or lending decision.
Educational content only. Not a commitment to lend, a rate quote, or an offer of credit. Programs, rates, fees, and guidelines are subject to change without notice; not all borrowers will qualify. Todd Hanley, RICP® | NMLS #1013665 | United Direct Lending NMLS #1749719 | Equal Housing Opportunity.